- This topic has 10 replies, 1,500 voices, and was last updated 17 years ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
I dont know what others think, but i think Jeff has done a great job as a new member of SP. I can actually say that it would really bother me if Iha decided to come back now. I wouldn’t want to see Jeff go. He seems like a good guy, he is obviously a great guitarist, and is not what i would consider a temporary member. Im not taking anything from Ginger, she rocks too. This topic really involves both, what do u think? Keep one of them, both, neither?
-
I can actually say that it would really bother me if Iha decided to come back now.[/quote:3hsbhffl]
You are assuming a lot here:
– that they asked James to join the renewed Pumpkins but that he decided not to
– that James can come back whenever he feels likeI don’t think you should do that, because as far as I know, that is pure speculation. We don’t know what happened. The first one could be true or false, the second one seems very unlikely to me.
-
-
Both can stay, and hopefully they will. Same for Lisa by the way. They produce a genuine Smashing Pumpkins sound altogether to my opinion. And Cool As Ice Cream is right, as far as I’m concerned we can not know now if Iha was ever concerned to come back. Even Melissa who openly sollicited for her place back in the Pumpkins was eventually not chosen or contacted. And Iha said he was never contacted I remember now…
-
-
-
-
-
seen them twice now – rock am ring and Shepheards bush, I was totally apprehensive at first, as in Billy’s gone and got himself some ringers. On those two occassions Jeff was great, I was up the front and in the pit for both shows and there was some nice chemistry going on between Jeff and BC. He can shred. Having seen the pumpkins 6 times before, as a wee child, it didnt make me pine for what could have been.
-
seen them twice now – rock am ring and Shepheards bush, I was totally apprehensive at first, as in Billy’s gone and got himself some ringers. On those two occassions Jeff was great, I was up the front and in the pit for both shows and there was some nice chemistry going on between Jeff and BC. He can shred. Having seen the pumpkins 6 times before, as a wee child, it didnt make me pine for what could have been.[/quote:2hdmaxxr]
this makes me believe..
a little. ill see for myself on oct 11 -
-
and judging by ‘a day in the life of the pumpkins’ he seems quite settled and comfortable, and the others seem to have warmed to him well 
The forum ‘General’ is closed to new topics and replies.
